One lesson that we learned the hard way when first setting out to travel as a family is that the more conveniently packed your infant formula is for you, the less convenient it is to bring it through airport security. Officially, the TSA must let you carry through a “reasonable” quantity of formula, water or any other liquid that your child may need. Unofficially, it has been my experience that it will be made inconvenient for you at the security checkpoint unless you do it a certain way.
Pre-mixed formula is your friend
When packing for a trip with a baby, I absolutely recommend being conservative with your carry on. That means packing enough food, water, diapers and other necessities to last the duration of the flight, airport waiting time, plus some additional allowance for delays. While I would like to stay out of the formula debate, if you happen to be at the stage where your child is drinking it, liquid pre-mixed formula is an incredible convenience for a number of reasons. It’s ready to drink, shelf (or backpack!) stable for a long time and won’t hypothetically cake you in a cement-like substance if you happen to make a wrong move. Something like this ought to fit the bill, right?
These come in nice, stackable packaging, contain enough for a solid serving and if sealed will certainly stay fresh. You absolutely should not carry these on. That’s not a typo. The first of multiple times that we tried to carry these through, the TSA was having none of it. To a parent, this is a convenient container. To the TSA, it’s an opaque container full of who knows what. They cannot test these in their liquid equipment, so my experience has ranged from them insisting that I open it to submitting to a full search and allowing me to leave it sealed. The former case complies with the letter of the regulation – at no point did they deny I could carry it through, it just wouldn’t be sealed, and therefore ready to spoil before takeoff. The latter scenario still makes no sense to me, other than to offer up a search as a deterrent. Assuming you’re not like me and don’t take the “I’m going to make it so awkward for them” mindset into a pat down, I will offer up an alternative. These –
Right off the bat, your parental sensibilities make you want to throw these at me for suggesting it. They hold 3 ounces instead of 8, are round instead of square and are glass instead of cardboard. You need 2 or 3 of these for every 1 of the cartons and the packaging is heavier to boot. These will, however, be met with no resistance by the TSA, because they can put them in the magic liquid scanner due to the mysterious transparent property of glass. Bringing these is a matter of net convenience. And science! Maybe. What I do ultimately suggest doing is carrying enough of the glass bottles to get you to your destination. Pack the cartons in your luggage so that you have them on arrival, or if weight/bag fees are a concern, swing by the store and buy a case on the way to the hotel.
But I don’t want to carry glass jars of formula
That’s fine. Neither do I, really. There is another way. It is slightly less convenient than pre-mixed formula and slightly more difficult when working with the TSA, but it falls within the regulations (that we know of) and ends up being a good compromise. The “recipe” –
- Multiple bottles with lids, plus nipples that screw on. I suggest separate lids because they aid in the mixing process and keep things from leaking after the fact. One bottle per anticipated feeding
- Gallon zip top bags
- Powdered formula
- Bottled water
Before you leave the house, take each very dry bottle and add enough powder for one feeding. Put the lid on it. Pack the bottles plus nipples in a zip top bag. Pack an extra zip top bag or two, completely empty. Pack enough bottled water to mix said formula. When you need it, you’ll just pour water into the bottle, shake and serve. When finished, put the spent bottle in the extra zip lock bag – preferably using the lid instead of the nipple – to contain leaks. This method is very convenient because you don’t have any powder to dump on yourself. It’s already in the bottle. It does involve carrying bottled water, though, so TSA will ask and possibly lecture you. You are allowed a “reasonable” amount, so stand firm that what you’re carrying is needed to mix formula. I once had a TSA agent give me a hard time at PHL because she thought I had “too much” bottled water, and started asking about my flight plans. I was polite, and recommend you do the same, but I added up the total flight time, airport time, and transportation to the hotel. She listened to me, but decided to get a supervisor involved. All I overheard from their conversation was, “It’s for a baby. Just let them go.” My point is, it’ll be obvious to some, but not to others, so be polite and patient, but it is your right to bring water for your child.
But formula is evil!
I’m not entering this debate! Some do it out of choice, some do it out of necessity. Some supplement, some switch after the first year. I’m going to hang out on the sideline for that debate and just tell you how to do it conveniently if you choose to. I do know my wife pumped for an entire year because our daughter refused breast-feeding directly – at least consistently, so I admire her resolve. After the first year, we switched to formula. In either case, clear containers are your friend at the security checkpoint.
Naturally, my way isn’t the only way. What tips, tricks and lessons have you learned?
Excellent and useful post. Gonna bookmark this. We’re breast-feeding for now, but he won’t be four months old forever (or even for two more weeks).
Glad tohelp! 4 months is a great age. They’re starting to do fun things beyond eating and needing diapers 🙂
This post was honestly unplanned, but I was randomly remembering the issues we had getting formula through security. It sounds kind of obvious after the fact, but when you have a little kid there are so many “obvious” things to prioritize – and making the TSA happy is probably at the bottom of your list.
Preach on. Have had more issues with shelf stable milk for toddlers than with formula personally, but principle is the same. TSA finds many ways to screw this one up.
One tip that has served me well with current baby #2 once I quit breastfeeding…. Enfamil now makes these great little individual sleeves/packets that contain enough powdered formula to make 4 oz of formula. Sold in boxes of 16. You can open/tear them by hand. We SWEAR by these for airline travel and even for some use around our hometown on the go. We buy bottled water on the sterile side of security, bring a few bottles, and are all set. Have not had a TSA issue liquids with Baby #2 yet (hope I don’t jinx myself now). These sleeves didn’t exist when my 5 year old was a baby, but I’ve certainly been telling every traveling parent I can find now about them!
Those sleeves are very convenient. Unfortunately our daughter and Enfamil just did not agree. Gerber Good Start was the only one that really sat well with her – I think it’s one of the few whey-based infant formulas, or something like that. What was nice about the 3oz jars is that you could grab some cheap nipples and throw them away when done – the threads were the same as most bottles.
We haven’t even tried to bring shelf-stable milk through. We figure there’s a Starbucks on the other side of security at most airports, so we buy a cup of it there and pour it into a take and toss.
Brought shelf stable milk all the time and no one ever gave it a second look at my home airports of SFO and OAK. Probably because they see it all in the crazy Bay Area. But I got some serious full body patdowns for my troubles when bringing it through smaller airports.
Really? I’ve just never tried because of the “open it” requests I’ve gotten here out east. The only one that offered the “compromise” of bringing it through if I got a patdown was my home airport, PWM. They were super apologetic about it too, not that it helps, but that’s the only time I got it through. We do pack a bunch in our luggage for the destination, though. And to think, I was the weird kid 25 years ago because I knew what Parmalat was!
Thanks for the helpful post. Could you give some more details on how things played out at security. Namely, did you have an unopened bottle of water or opened? Did you put it on the belt? Did you also put the powder and or the bottles on the belt to make it obvious? Did you announce your bottle before they asked?
Whenever we brought bottled water for our little one, it was unopened. My goal isn’t ever to have an issue with TSA, so I know that a sealed bottle is likely to be a lot easier. I did put it on the belt. As far as the bottles with powder, no, I just leave them in my carry on. They aren’t liquids or otherwise “special” so I leave them in. I don’t recall an issue with those, just the bottled water.
I’m not the type to hassle the TSA, but I do know the rules and when it comes to my kid, I’ll hold my ground. I wasn’t about to toss my bottled water because the agent didn’t like the quantity. The fact that she was dismissed very quickly by her supervisor suggests that this should not have at all been an edge case.
Thanks for the feedback. I agree with your train of thought. They can tell me to place my shoes on my head and Walk through the scanner backwards and I won’t complain, but if they give me a problem about my infants food, I’m going to fight back. Hopefully following your tips I won’t need to.
We were advised by friends to bring water on and just say it was for the baby (even though we didn’t use powdered formula). Not sure if it’s because we were using TSA Pre, but we never had a problem with water bottles, bottles filled with breast milk, etc. They would just take them and put them in the magic machine and then let us go. I think the largest bottle we ever brought was the 8 oz. Dr. Brown’s – actually that was regular whole milk this past May. That fit in the magic machine too. I think lids is a great suggestion and the nipples help too I think – it looks more innocent!
Oh and we always announced everything we were bringing in as soon as we got to the agent.
Water doesn’t need to be paired with powdered formula. For whatever reason, some kids drink straight water too, and they need access to it quickly. We brought 8oz Dr. Browns through as well, but not often. Formula “officially” has a recommended life of 1 hour at room temp, unlike breastmilk which can sit out all day. So we stopped bringing full bottles through when we switched to formula – once we went to formula, it was in the glass jars if we could find them, or the powder + bottled water if I forgot to get the jars from Amazon.
On the whole, I do find that they’re much easier to work with when you use TSA Pre, but the same rules do apply. It’s just that the ratio of TSA agents to passengers is higher, so they don’t seem to get tired and start shouting at people 🙂
I don’t envy TSOs. Most are decent folks earning a living. They don’t make the policies, and sometimes they have to enforce what they haven’t really been fully trained on. No matter what, I never raise my voice and just try to bring it back to calm and professional, and things usually work out.
The only other truly memorable TSA story I have is when we went to Italy this past winter. Terminal E has no pre-check. The TSO at BOS sent me through the body scanner because I had gotten “too far” from my family and couldn’t go through the metal detector with them. I opted out, so he instructed the agent behind him to make me wait. Very professional. But I digress.
Haha. Good old Terminal E. I didn’t realize the shelf life of formula, that makes a lot more sense then. Not sure what we’re gonna do with our whole milk next week since that stuff don’t last – any suggestions?
At BOS you can definitely get milk behind security. If you need shelf stable for a long flight, try brining to security and see if they’ll let it through. I can’t remember if E has any shops that sell the stable cartons,but vaguely recall that they do. If not get a cup of milk at the Starbucks counter you’d be surprised how long it lasts, at least a few hrs if it’s cold to start. Bring a thermos and ask them to fill it and that may well last a transatlantic.
Shelf-stable milk is allowed, just to be clear. But you may confused TSOs in the process. Stand your ground (nicely of course) if questioned. I’ve never NOT been allowed to take it through – I usually just have to get patted down when I explain that I can’t open it or it will spoil. Most of the time I don’t get a second look though. Especially in big airports.
Not a parent, but I bookmarked this for future reference, seems a great system.
My home airport is JFK. Never had a problem with TSA. I bring 1 bottle with water and 2 empty – depending of the length of the flight/Dr. Browns brand. The formula goes in a nifty container from OXO with space for 3 servings. I also have on my carry on 1 can of formula just in case. After security I stopped by any lounge (gotta love the credit card game)and get some free water.
My son is 16 months old and we are going to Brazil to visit family on a 9 hour flight. I find more challenging because he refuses any type of jar food, so I have to bring all kinds of snacks/fruits to keep him happy. Also daddy is staying in NYC to work and mommy goes alone with a toddler. Wish me luck.
Keep up the good work. Traveling with kids is hard but very rewarding.