We just completed a seven credit card app-o-rama for Mrs. PFD. Five applications resulted in instant approvals and two were deferred. Here’s the rundown:
AMEX BUSINESS REWARDS GOLD: Instant approval, $5,000 minimum spend. My wife set up a side business last fall and recently she had the good fortune to get targeted for a 75,000-point Business Gold offer with the first-year fee waived. She was also targeted for a 100,000 Platinum card offer, but that one did not have the fee waived, and with the lounge access going away, the extra 25,000 points and the $200 credit don’t make up for the annual fee. Please use the comments below to explain what a wondrous product the Platinum is and what a horrible mistake we made in not getting it. Go on, I dare you. What? All right then, didn’t think so.
CITI PLATINUM ADVANTAGE: Instant approval with a healthy credit line, 50,000 miles, $3K minimum spend. I love Citi so much! One of these days, we will stop having kids and will be ready for one of those nice vacations where you fly on a plane to a nice place to see and do nice things, and the PFD household will have some AA miles stockpiled for that day. And hopefully American won’t get all Delta-y on us in the meantime.
BARCLAYCARD ARRIVAL: Deferred. This, of course, would be the 40,000-point, $3K minimum spend offer. Also, I have an affiliate link for this offer and all of you should sign up for this card immediately, unless you already have it, which you almost certainly do, so I’m really wasting everybody’s time here with my half-assed marketing pitch. Anyway: if approved, I plan to use part of the bonus to pay for three nights at Holiday Inns so that we can claim a 100,000-point Big Win from Priority Club. Aside from that, no immediate plans for those points, though I’m sure we’ll think of something.
CHASE: We gave them a rest this time around. They have a lot of great travel deals, but we’re short on travel time and travel energy at the moment.
THAT WELLS FARGO 5% CASH BACK CARD: Deferred, I’m curious to see what happens here. My wife applied for this one last fall but they rejected her on the grounds that her income was too low. And that’s interesting, because they had no problem approving me, and my wife and I have exactly the same amount of income, what with the whole marriage thing. My theory is that the guy who took her application in-branch marked her income down as zero since she’s a homemaker. We called the recon line and asked them to think it over and they responded a few days later saying that my wife’s income is too low. Ladies and gentlemen, a round of applause for Wells Fargo!
We let it go because my wife was about 23 months pregnant (or so it seemed at the time), but it’s worth another try.
TOYS R US MASTERCARD AND DILLARD’S AMEX: Instant approvals, albeit with small credit lines ($1,200 and $800), These are both GE cards, so I figured I’d investigate them for you, my internet friends, to see if they’re any good. If they are, the PFD household will have no problem spending any gift cards that come our way.
Thinking more broadly about GE, I like the idea of cultivating a crop of credit cards I can occasionally harvest whenever the marketing conditions are right. And “credit card farming” would be a cool-sounding title for this hobby, too.
FUEL REWARDS MASTERCARD: Instant approval. I’m curious to see what Comenity Bank is like, and I figure a card like this is as likely as any to have some nice promos.
Speaking more generally about the last three cards, I’m a little bored with the current state of credit card coverage in the blogosphere. It’s over-saturated, but only for certain products, which is to say I will go insane if I see one more Boarding Area blogger remind me about that Friday restaurant promo for the Chase Sapphire. (I SEE WHAT YOU DID THERE, OKAY?) So I figure, let’s go off the beaten path a bit and see what happens. It’ll probably be nothing, but you never know.
HaleyB says
I couldn’t pass by a blog with a title like that.
marathon man says
Would this be followed by the “Kiddo-Rama”? should you have 18+ year olds laying around at home?
pfdigest says
LOL! Can kids get Bluebirds?
pfdigest says
When I went searching for images for this post, I was pleasantly surprised not to find anything too unsavory.
milesforfamily says
Credit card farming, LOL You come up with the funniest stuff! To use those pulls to investigate the cards for your readers, that is some serious commitment. I hope they reward you by applying for Arrival. Oh wait, everyone already got it!
MileageUpdate says
I read that headline and was like “Man PFD is one wild and crazy guy”
Marathon man says
Oh so you mean like… Hes a mormon? Lol
pfdigest says
Or possibly a 1970s-era Czechoslovakian immigrant.
Marathon man says
1970s czech immigrants sounds like a band name
But do they ms? Now that is the real question
pfdigest says
In case anybody was wondering, the Czech thing was an SNL reference. Dan Aykroyd and Steve Martin, I think.
Marathon man says
Oh geez i shoulda caught that
Dayum im slippin
pfdigest says
It’s not completely selfless on my part, I’m hoping it’ll be worth my while.
HT says
X Platinum
March 2014 $200 credit
Jan 2015 another calender year $200 credit
Global Entry fee paid by X $100
and 100K MR
plus possible reimbursement for loosing United/Delta lounge access $ ???
cancel card in Feb 2015
this work$ out in my book
Glenn says
Was going to post the same thing. Apply partway through a calendar year. Get $200 credit immediately. At the start of the next year, get another $200 credit. Then cancel before 2nd fee.
Note though that the fee reimbursements have been getting more difficult, though lately the use of the Gift Card registry for United has made it easy again. So I’d say if you’re happy with United credits then great. Otherwise maybe not. You’ll have to investigate the latest reports of what gets reimbursed before you execute, and you may end up with a bunch of odd-value gift cards.
Also I’d be interested if Amex will offer anybody who applied for a Platinum AFTER the loss of lounge access news will be seeing a credit. I wouldn’t bet on it. I bet its a one-time thing this year.
Caleb B says
Have you cycled through your CL multiple times on a GE issued card?
I’m trying to find out if they’re more like Citi or Wells.
pfdigest says
I have not as they haven’t pulled an MS-able promotion on me, but I’m pretty sure MilesAbound has–check out his take on the Banana Republic card.