• We just rolled out a huge software update for the Forum to bring us into the 20th Century. There's still a couple of kinks that we are working out. Let us know if you encounter any problems and we will have them squared away quickly.

Physical vs e-gift cards for resale


Silver Member
I'm considering buying some gift cards to sell on cardpool.

I have never sold a gift card before but thought I'd try a few to get to know how the process works.

In the cases I'm considering I would buy the card(s) and set a sale price.

I'm wondering if there are distinct advantages to physical gift cards or e-gift cards that impact their saleability.

I know that I usually seek out e-gift cards because when I decide to purchase something I don't want to wait for the card to be shipped to me. Is it possible to convert a physical gift card to an e-gift card?
There's a lot to learn about reselling GCs and the different exchanges. It depends on the brand if a physical card can be sold as an e-card. Most of the time they can, but exchanges have a "Do Not Buy" list and specify limitations based on the brand. You need to know the market, if it's saturated or not, what does and doesn't sell based on the time of the year, the listing fees that can be as high as 12%, etc. You might want to research giftcard reselling before jumping in and/or go with a bulk buyer.
Had a bad experience the very first time I tried to do this. Did the math and saw that I could get a $200 worth of gift cards at a discount from one site, then sell them at another for a small profit. I purchased 2 gift cards for Icing, but when they arrived, they were both for Claire's. I complained, and was told that the Claire's gift cards would work at Icing because they were run by the same company. That's probably true, but the site I had targeted to sell them to was paying a lot more for Icing gift cards than for Claire gift cards. I requested a return and full refund, and finally got it after threatening to file a complaint with the FTC over false advertising. Lots of headache, lots of time wasted, nothing gained.