I like to draw from my experiences of living and training in martial arts in Japan. What I loved most about when I found true masters to train with is that there was complete congruence between intellectual concept and physical interpretation. In martial arts Kihon is the word that applies to basics, fundamentals. This is not unlike learning to walk before you can run.
The Kihon is that fundamental knowledge that often comes before the technique – to take it to an extreme before you can walk you must understand balance, depth perception, how to adapt, change pace etc. This learning process is not always conscious, and frequently people will create a reasonably successful approach to something from deductive logic, and most people will figure out how to run at some point.
Just like a sprinter would break down his movement, looking backwards to his balance and his weight distribution, a martial artist will constantly explore balance points, weight, timing, distance and directions, and with each level of self realization a strong final product is created.
This refinement process for a true artist or athlete will go right down to the fundamentals, and at other times will tweak things at a very high level. There is a great danger that exists in the novice observer, they may look onward and seek to copy what they see, but they are missing fundamental knowledge, they see a person doing a throw, but don’t know that the person wasn’t allowed to try that until they had 200 hours of learning how to receive the throw as Uke.
I see this existing within the personal finance space too, and I am guilty of playing with very esoteric concepts for money and travel. I feel that perhaps we should have a new disclaimer “professional driver on a closed course” just to make sure that people don’t recklessly emulate.
In martial arts and sports, there are no shortcuts. During my current training every now and then I get to go up against a few Olympians, these guys work on the basics every single day and that is why they become champions, they certainly also refine at the highest level, but they got through all of the basic, boring steps because if they do not drill the boring stuff gaps in their knowledge will emerge when under extreme pressure. When you train against them you know that there is something fundamentally different, and even the most mundane technique becomes a serious risk.
As an example, I like the idea of talking about using a ROTH IRA as an emergency fund, but this isn’t for everyone. In fact it is hard to know exactly who it is for… if you look at the people with the least savings who would benefit most, they often don’t have the fortitude to keep their ROTH funds liquid, rather chasing yields, if you look at people at the top end of the spectrum who have enough wealth to not need to do this, it is worthless.
Another might be DCbroker and his method, are people going to skip past the slow and steady approach to earning some miles from a normal spend and go all in from the start? I certainly hope not.
There are some people who fit in the middle ground of knowledge who can do really well from strategies like this, but I think it might be wise if you think you fit into this slice of demographic that you first do things the boring, ineffective way, the ‘proper’ way. It won’t be flashy, you will lose a little upside in the opportunity, but you will learn your Kihon. Once you have internalized the concepts, then refine them.
Jumping straight from nothing and no knowledge to extremely sophisticated might well cause you more problems that it is worth, remember, nobody becomes a champion, financial or capturing snazzy deals or otherwise by cutting corners before they know how the corner works.
For more ramblings on Martial Arts, and some pics of someone trying to kick my backside, check out this post on Traveling as a Martial Artist.
ucipass says
I love your writing style. You definitely have talent. You could have just wrote: “learn to walk before you try to run”.
I was really smiling when you mentioned on your last post that you wanted to punch your last critique in the face, but I guess, you have some “street cred’ with your martial art training. LOL
Matt says
Thanks! I wanted to address the point plus bring a bit more of ‘me’ to the blog.
I don’t punch readers in the face 🙂
Xavier says
Yet… 🙂
JustSaying says
Great post and great under current to this entire endeavor. As a retired Army officer now chasing miles I view the March madness as the frequent flyer version of Army Ranger school. Sleep depravation, starvation, being forced to lead in a degraded physical state. And sometimes you crash and burn and many, many Ranger candidates are medical washouts, physical fitness washouts, mental washouts, etc. It has a high washout rate for the very reason that it wants to select only the very best. To get there we need your Ranger school and for me it gives me the momentum to continue what Frequent Miler started last March Madness. My hat is off to you guys……..to your aggressive quest and to the ethos that you approach it.
Matt says
Thank you for your service. I am glad that you are keeping busy in retirement with the new hobby, and pleased that we are able to find that line where it is interesting and inspiring without giving the game away.
Cheers,
Matt
JustSaying says
LOL! I’m not retired as after Army days moved to San Francisco thanks to VA employment. So my retired Army officer wife gets to do the daily Staples and drugstore runs. I have her in training much as the Madness has me in training. It is such a wonderful intellectual puzzle with such smart players.
Matt says
Ahh… OK well you still have my thanks, and I hope full retirement happens sometime soon! I train with a few ex military types, one young marine who is far too big but thankfully very happy go lucky, and an ex Ranger/Delta guy that doesn’t have the body for it anymore, but the mental toughness is scary.